Last Sunday I was privileged to get to teach. I love teaching, and have been given a gift to be able to teach well… or so I’ve been told. My biggest challenge right now is that I don’t have a regular teaching venue, so when I am given the opportunity to teach, it’s generally one session. But when I start preparing, I often end up with a 7 part series. I love to study (stuff I’m interested in) and my brain can find itself off on incredible journeys in the midst of those studies, yielding lots to say about lots of stuff. There’s probably more than a little wisdom in only giving me limited engagements. This blog serves as an outlet for some of that pent-up teaching desire. The good news is that you’re not stuck here, and you won’t be obvious if you get up and leave… In fact, the stat tracker on this site doesn’t have any way of knowing if you read the whole thing, or if you’ve already surfed back out. You already count as one of my dozen or so readers!
Last week’s topic was “Doubt.” I’m not sure how I arrived at this topic; I started thinking about what I was going to teach, and one interesting thought led to another, which led to another, and pretty soon I had taken an interesting journey through many amazing places, winding up on this amazing topic, with no idea how I got there, and not completely sure how I was going to get back. If you’ve ever been on a snowmachining adventure I’ve led, you can completely understand.
Two things made “doubt” a compelling topic:
1) I’ve been reading a really interesting book called You Lost Me. The book recounts results from a landmark study by the Barna Group, which looked at 16-29 year olds (the “Mosaic” generation) through the lens of faith. Subtitled “Why Young Christians are Leaving Church… and Rethinking Faith,” the book provides tremendous insight into an intriguing and underappreciated generation. (As an aside, if anyone is interested in reading it, I bought it through my Kindle app, and I can “loan” it to “anyone I choose” according to the Amazon website–if you’re interested in reading it let me know, and together we can discover how loaning e-books works.) It turns out doubt hasn’t been handled well in church, and is a major factor in the tremendous decline of Christian faith in Mosaics.
2) My wife sent me this well-written editorial shortly after the Sandy Hook shootings: “Why, God?” In it, the author reprints a letter written by a Catholic priest in response to the title question. The priest’s bold, insightful answer: “I don’t know.” BRAVO!
Over the years, Christianity has often held up doubt as the opposite of faith. I can see how this occurred, but it’s not accurate. In fact, doubt, or the potential for doubt, is a necessary ingredient for faith. Faith, or pisteuo in Greek, is also often translated in the Bible as “believe,” which is unfortunate, because “believe” doesn’t capture the full meaning of pisteuo. We use the word “believe” to mean “mental assent”–I agree that something is correct or true–I believe it. I can even believe someone by giving my mental assent to what they’re saying. But pisteuo has a much deeper meaning than mere “mental assent.” For someone to have faith, they must not only give mental assent, but they must act on that belief as if it were true, and must have some element of risk associated with that belief. I can believe (mental assent) I can fly by flapping my arms, I can even act on it by standing on the ground flapping furiously, but I don’t have faith in that belief until I jump off the roof and try to fly. Silly analogy, but hopefully it helps clarify the distinction.
Doubt, in the Greek, is apisteuo, or “not-faith”. This is an inadequate translation though, because it is certainly not the opposite of faith. I characterize doubt as a condition where the three elements of mental assent, trust, and risk are not fully developed. For instance, you might doubt the assertion, meaning you are not ready to assent to its veracity. Or, you might think something is true, but you’re not so confident in your belief that you’re willing to act on it, or to take a risk based on that belief. This is doubt. It’s not wrong, it’s not weak, it’s just not fully bought in. Doubt is a difficulty reconciling seemingly contradictory concepts.
Doubt isn’t a defect. It’s normal. In fact, it’s a necessary ingredient. One of the most profound statements I have heard in years comes from my senior pastor, who said “you can’t have faith without doubt.” Doubt is not the problem in our world today. The problem with doubt is we often mishandle it….