I’ve got more to say than will fit in a Tweet…
My news feed is blowing up with highly distorted references to a “Harvard Study” that allegedly presents a “shocking conclusion” and “pokes a massive hole in Black Lives Matter claims.” I’m not linking to this internet propaganda that masquerades as journalism; if you want to see it plug the quotes into your favorite search engine.
Here’s a better NY Times article on the study. While the skewed articles are factually correct in their statement that the study found no racial bias in police shootings, they leave out critical findings from the study. A more accurate summary of the findings, from the study itself (it’s 63 pages, but over half is statistical data and tables, it’s not too difficult of a read, if you’re interested in facts and details):
On non-lethal uses of force, there are racial differences- sometimes quite large– in police use of force, even after accounting for a large set of controls designed to account for important contextual and behavioral factors at the time of the police-civilian interaction. Interestingly, as the use of force increases from putting hands on a civilian to striking them with a baton, the overall probability of such an incident occurring decreases dramatically but the racial difference remains roughly constant. Even when officers report civilians have been compliant and no arrest was made, blacks are 21.3 percent more likely to endure some form of force. Yet, on the most extreme uses of force– officer-involved shootings- we are unable to detect any racial differences in either the raw data or when accounting for controls. (p35, emphasis added)
I could expend another couple of paragraphs detailing how what the report actually says in no way punches holes in the Black Lives Matter argument, or vindicates those who oppose it. But that’s not the real point of this post.
Significant numbers of the African American community are telling us in multiple different ways, from tweets, blogs, speeches, sermons, and protests, that there is a problem. When us white folks answer with “All Lives Matter,” or with statistics purporting to tell them that they are wrong, we are totally missing the point. THERE IS A PROBLEM!!! We can have a discussion about what the problem is, or how we solve it, or even about whether the problem is one of fact vs. perception, but that requires a willingness to have a dialog first. If your answer fits in a tweet, or a meme, particularly if it points out how the other party is wrong, or how the problem doesn’t exist, you have failed at dialog before even demonstrating a willingness to participate.
“The further away we are from a problem, the simpler it looks…. Most of us, from where we sit as white people, we are far away from what you’re talking about. We just are. We believe you, it’s a reality (Greg’s note: I would argue that this isn’t always accurate), but it’s still so far away and our answers, our emotional response is so simplistic.
“The closer you get to a problem, the more complex it becomes, because the closer you get to any problem there is the actual facts.”
We have to quit throwing out simplistic answers (“just comply”) or statistics and “facts” that deny the problem (see above), or pithy statements that dismiss the problem (“All Lives Matter”). These do nothing but degrade our African American brothers and sisters. We need to listen. We need to lean in. We need to get closer to the problem, so we start understanding it. If you don’t think there is a problem, you’re too far away. Sit down with the mom of an African American teenage boy, and ask her what she fears. Ask her what she teaches her son about being pulled over by the police. Listen.
Stop being defensive. The African American community is not calling you or me an explicit racist. What they’re trying desperately to tell us is that there is bias in the system, and it’s hurting them, it’s creating fear, and we need to help. If your solution is a study to prove that the problem doesn’t exist, maybe you need to lean in a little more.
One more thought for my Christian brothers and sisters: Prayer is vital, and necessary. I implore you to pray, but not some lame prayer of “Jesus, fix what’s going on in our country.” He empowered the solution 50 days after his crucifixion. Jesus’s solution for addressing what’s going on in the world today is, and has been the same for the last 2000 years–the Church.
Instead, I ask you to pray the prayer that Andy suggests:
“Prejudice and racism are almost impossible to see in the mirror because it’s hidden in our hearts…. Would you ask God to do for you what he did for Peter (in Acts 10:28)? Would you ask God to show you? Would you say ‘God, I think I’m good with this, I think I’m free and clear.’… Regardless of your experience, would you at least have the courage to say, ‘God, show me. Help me to spot it and despise it the way that you do. Help me to despise it and to stop defending it. And give me the courage to eradicate it from my heart, rather than keep telling myself that same story over and over and over that justifies it in my heart.’ “
But when you’ve prayed, don’t consider your role finished. As Christians, we need to act. Andy’s concluding words:
The church has to be at the epicenter of this. Only in the church are we taught that I am looking at someone who is made in the image of God…. You cannot mistreat my children and get along with me, and I cannot mistreat you and get along with my Father in Heaven. That is the message of the New Testament, and that is the message of the Cross, and that trumps my experience, and your experience.
Lean in. Get close to your brothers and sisters–so close that the problem is not “theirs,” but “ours.” And when your response begins with, “But…” stop and listen again.